Last time, I wrote about the greatest Michigan games in recent history that I attended or wish I had attended. My list was missing a few great games of the past decade (almost all of the 1994-1997 seasons) because I missed all of those games because of competitive high school marching band ruining my Saturdays.
This time, I am going to drudge up memories of games I really wish I could repress permanently. Here are the five most heartbreaking losses I attended as well as the most heartbreaking losses I saw on TV.
Five Most Heartbreaking Losses Attended:
2001 - MICHIGAN STATE 26, Michigan 24Two days before taking an actuarial exam, a full-day road trip with the band to East Lansing for a 3:30PM football game was not high on my list of things I wanted to do. I was just a
little stressed out at the time (especially since I failed this exam six months earlier). However, I was not about to miss this game against the hated Spartans. It really looked like Michigan was going to finally roll over MSU and get a big road win. The BCS title was not yet out of the question for the 1-loss Wolverines with their fairly easy closing schedule (OSU was weak this year).
MSU was missing their top three defensive backs, so all Michigan had to do was throw the ball to Marquise Walker all game. The first half was the Marquise Walker show. I think he had about 120yds receiving and 2 TDs in the first 30 minutes, but Michigan was only up something like 14-10 at halftime.
The defenses took over in the second half, but the Michigan offense stopped throwing to their unstoppable WR. MSU took a 20-17 lead and had the ball with about 7 minutes to play when Michigan recovered a fumble on the MSU 35 yard line. Michigan, facing a third and long, found unlikely target Jermaine Gonzales in the back of the end zone to take a lead.
Michigan would get the ball back with a chance to end the game with one first down. However, in classic Lloydball fashion, the offense played it very close to the vest, went three-and-out, and MSU took over possession with 1-2 minutes left. MSU appeared to be stopped by the Michigan defenses when a 4th and long pass sailed incomplete. However, DB Jeremy LeSeur was flagged for illegal hands to the face while covering Charles Rogers on the other side of the field. MSU took advantage of the play and drove to the Michigan 1 yard line, where Jeff Smoker was tackled in bounds with 11 seconds left. The refs sprinted to place the ball, and Smoker snapped the ball with 1 second left. Amazingly, the ball was snapped, hit the ground, the ref signaled the end of the play, and the clock operator reacted and stopped the clock all with 1 second left. Yeah, Right. I was sitting next to the UM bench and everyone was LIVID! MSU got a gift extra play from the 1 yard line, got away with
a blatant hold on the UM DE , and Smoker found TJ Duckett in the end zone. Oh man did that ending suck. That was not a good Spartan team in 2001. They had no business winning that game. While the ending was pure BS, Michigan should have not even let the Spartans hang around that day. Bad things happen in Spartan Stadium to Lloyd Carr led teams after the sun goes down.
Check out the WJR transcript of the last minute. Unfortunately, I can't find an audio clip of the call. THIEVERY!
2001 - Ohio State 26, MICHIGAN 20
This one was not a screw job, just a demoralizing loss that was not nearly as close as the final score indicates. All Michigan had to do was win at home against OSU, something they had done every time since 1987, to secure the Big Ten title and a trip to the Sugar Bowl in New Orleans. OSU had a new coach, four losses, and had just benched QB Steve Belli"sorry" because of legal issues. This game should have been in the bag. However, things went terribly wrong. Some of the memories from my last home game as a member of the marching band:
- Just before the senior MMB members were to be honored on senior day, we sat in the corner of the end zone and watched Jonathan Wells rush for 50 yards on 4th-and-1 right in front of us to give OSU a 14-0 lead.
- Navarre finally gets benched just before halftime and OSU gets a safety when the ball is snapped over QB Jermaine Gonzales's head, giving the Buckeyes a 23-0 halftime lead.
- Michigan mounts a great comeback, but sure handed WR Marquise Walker drops a sure touchdown on a 3rd down pass that would have made the game close late in the third quarter.
- Cold rain comes down right after the game ends (it had been dreary and drizzly all day), and we have to stand on the field in the rain and wait to start our post game show until after the OSU players get off our damn field and stop celebrating.
What a terrible senior day. Michigan falls into the Citrus Bowl for the third time in my four years of school. It was a crushing loss to an OSU team that was really not that good (but very well prepared).
2000 - UCLA 23, Michigan 20 I traveled out to Santa Barbara to spend an extended weekend with my brother and attend the big game at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena. It was a hot day, with the temperature topping out at well over 100 degrees.
The teams were very evenly matched, but the difference was one official on the UCLA sideline. He robbed Michigan's defensive back (LeSeur or Curry) of an obvious interception by ruling that he was out of bounds (UCLA would score a TD on that drive). He also tried to call a BS pass interference penalty on Michigan late in the game that other officials overturned because the pass was only 15 feet over the receiver's head. Every bad call in that game was made by the ref on the UCLA sideline, and they were all in UCLA's favor.
However, the real cause of the loss was the two missed FGs by enigmatic K Hayden Epstein, including a missed 25-yarder in the last six minutes. Michigan was also driving in the last two minutes of the game, but John Navarre threw an ill-advised pass that was picked off inside the UCLA 20. This was supposed to be a great Michigan team. In fact, it was a great team that went 9-3 with three losses by 3 points or less. However, the preseason injury to Drew Henson and the pathetic defense kept this team from reaching their potential.
1999 - Illinois 35, MICHIGAN 29 This game cost us a Rose Bowl trip in 1999. It was the one of the craziest fourth quarters I have seen. Michigan one led 27-7 during the second half. Who would have thought that a missed extra point would change the tone of the game? Illinois came back with three straight touchdowns, and Michigan trailed by one point about halfway through the fourth quarter (thanks to that damn missed XP). Tom Brady led the Wolverines into scoring range, but on 2nd-and-10 in Illinois territory, the ball was snapped over Brady's head. Michigan lost twenty-five yards on the play and the drive stalled.
Illinois needed one first down to run out the clock. RB Rocky Harvey got that first down, and then decided to take it all the way for a touchdown, giving Michigan the ball back down 35-27 with 1-2 minutes left. Once again, Brady drove Michigan down the field and inside the Illini 20-yard line. Unfortunately, Brady was intercepted on the 1. Amazingly, the Illini player tried running with the ball and was stripped. The ball rolled into the end zone, but Michigan was unable to win the race to the loose ball. Illinois recovered for a safety. Michigan got the ball back with a few seconds left and no timeouts, and they were unable to score a miraculous touchdown.
One of the worst choke jobs I have seen from a Michigan team.
1998 - Syracuse 38, MICHIGAN 28 Michigan was one year removed from a national title, but their defense, despite returning 9 or 10 starters, was exposed for the second week in a row and Michigan fell to 0-2. Syracuse provided the blueprint for beating Michigan that has held up for the past 7 years. Have a mobile QB. Donovan McNabb led the Orangemen to touchdowns or field goals on their first 5 drives of the game. On their sixth drive, Michigan finally held Syracuse to a missed FG, but the game was already well out of reach. The signature play was when Michigan was about to sack McNabb, but the lineman was only able to rip off McNabb's shoe. Donovan then scrambled 25 yards for a touchdown.
This was the only time I left a Michigan game early (I was not in the band this year). When Syracuse went up 38-7 early in the third quarter, I had enough. Sadly, about half of the fans had already left. Freshman QB Drew Henson led the team down the field twice in garbage time, but the game was not as close as the final score.
Two Most Heartbreaking Losses Watched on TV:
2000 - NORTHWESTERN 54, Michigan 51This game still has me speechless. No Michigan team should score 51 points in regulation time and lose. Ever. Jim Hermann should have been fired after this game. Northwestern's RB dropped a fourth down pass in the end zone late in the game, despite being wide open. Anthony Thomas had the game clinching first down (and many more yards) before dropping the football (I won't call it a fumble because he was not even touched). Northwestern comes back and wins. Michigan finishes tied for first in the Big Ten and does not go to the Rose Bowl because of this loss.
I was watching the game at the "shit-brown house" (I didn't live there at the time). We had a marching band concert that night at Hill Auditorium (Band-o-Rama). We were supposed to be there in full uniform by 7PM for warm-ups. The football game went past 7PM, and none of us at the house left for the concert. Definitely not with the game still undecided. By the time the game finally ended (7:15ish), we all rushed over to Hill in full uniform. To our surprise, about 1/3 of the band was still missing. We started the concert late that night, but no one was really in the mood for "Michigan cheer" that evening after the wildest Michigan game I have every watched.
1994 - Colorado 27, MICHIGAN 26
A week after a stunning last-second win at Notre Dame, #7 Colorado came into Ann Arbor to face #3 Michigan. (I miss the days when powerhouse teams would play non-conference games against each other in September)
I missed nearly the entire game since we had a high school marching band competition that afternoon. I got home with about 6 minutes left. Michigan was up by 12 points and had the ball. Unfortunately, the game turned quickly. Colorado scored a touchdown, but Michigan was unable to run out the clock on their next possession. With the ball on their inside their own 20 and 10 seconds left, Colorado didn't have many options. A quick short pass to the 30 or 35-yard line gave Kordell Stewart enough room to launch a desperation bomb on the last play of the game that could reach the end zone. Sadly, the Michigan defender (either Ty Law or Shonte Peoples) tipped the desperation pass up in the air. Michael Westbrook snuck in behind the play and caught the ball for a touchdown. I still remember the sinking feeling when Keith Jackson exclaimed, "There are no flags on the field". I know people who were at that game. They say that Michigan Stadium has never been quieter.